News & Insights

Eighty-four days. That’s the median number of days a home in Sarasota now sits on the market before selling.

To put that in perspective: just a couple of years ago, you practically had to tour a house with checkbook in hand because offers rolled in within days. Today, homes linger for nearly three months. Sellers wait. Buyers breathe.

Related Article: Navigating SRQ Airport: Your Complete Guide

That shift is more than just a stat — it’s leverage. For first-time buyers, especially in Sarasota and Manatee counties, this is a rare window of opportunity. Prices have softened. Inventory is growing. Sellers are more willing to negotiate. If you’ve been on the sidelines, wondering if homeownership on the Suncoast is within reach, the number 84 should get your attention.

Let’s dive into why this matters, how you can take advantage of it, and what smart, first-time buyers need to know right now.

Why Are Homes Taking Longer to Sell?

Markets move in cycles. Sarasota and Manatee counties experienced a post-pandemic surge: remote workers relocating, historically low interest rates, and limited inventory. The result? Frenzied bidding wars, cash buyers winning out, and skyrocketing prices.

But by mid-2025, the trend flipped:

• Sarasota County median sale price: $475,000, down 4.3% year-over-year.
• Median days on market: 84 (up 15 days from the previous year).
• Manatee County median sale price: $430,000, down 2.3% year-over-year.
• Median days on market: 75 (up 9 days).
  
  

Longer listing times signal a market cooling — and that gives buyers breathing room.

Why 84 Days Matters to First-Time Buyers

So what does nearly three months on the market mean in practice? Four powerful shifts:

1. Negotiating Room

With homes sitting unsold, sellers are more open to offers below asking price. A $390,000 home in Bradenton might close closer to $382,000. That’s real money back in your pocket.

2. Seller Concessions

You can now ask sellers to cover closing costs — often 2–3% of the purchase price. On a $350,000 home, that’s $7,000–$10,500 in upfront savings.

3. Time to Decide

Instead of rushing to submit an offer in 24 hours, you have time to schedule second showings, compare properties, and consult with your lender.

4. More Options

Higher inventory means more homes to choose from — whether that’s a starter condo in Sarasota Springs or a new build in Palmetto.

Actionable Strategies for Today’s Market

Here’s how first-time buyers can turn this stat into strategy.

Get Pre-Approved Early

Pre-approval shows sellers you’re serious and speeds up your timeline once you find a home. In Manatee County, this step also determines eligibility for powerful local programs:

• Manatee County Housing Finance Authority: Up to $15,000 in down payment assistance.
• Mortgage Credit Certificate (MCC): A 20% annual federal tax credit on mortgage interest, saving thousands over the life of the loan.
  
  

Use the 84-Day Window to Negotiate

Target homes that have been listed 60+ days. These sellers are ready to deal. Leverage that by:

• Offering below asking price (based on comps).
• Requesting closing cost assistance.
• Negotiating repairs after inspection instead of covering them yourself.
  
  

Do the Math on Total Costs

Don’t just look at purchase price. Factor in taxes, insurance, and HOA fees. Both counties offer online calculators:

• Sarasota County Property Tax Estimator
• Manatee County Property Tax Estimator
  
  

Focus on Value Over Shine

Cosmetic upgrades are easy to add. But a new roof or modern HVAC? That’s worth tens of thousands. Always prioritize structural soundness over granite countertops.

Where the Opportunities Are:
ZIP Code Profiles

The Sarasota-Manatee First-Time Homebuyer ZIP Code Report identifies five ZIP codes that stand out in 2025.

Here’s how the numbers line up with today’s 84-day reality:

34287 (North Port, Sarasota County) — The Affordability Champion

• Median home value: $261,231
• Median household income: $64,229
• Affordability Index: 4.07 (best in the region)
• Crime: 54% below national average

North Port combines low prices with high safety — a rare duo. Homes have also seen an 11% year-over-year price correction, creating even more leverage for buyers.

34203 (Bradenton, Manatee County) — The Balanced Contender

• Median sale price: $390,000
• Median income: $68,030
• Affordability Index: 5.73
• Highlight: Access to Manatee’s $15K down payment program

Buyers here benefit from affordability, good schools, and major community investments like the John Marble Recreation Center renovations.

34232 (Sarasota) — The Aspirational Suburb

• Median sale price: $362,138
• Median income: $81,041 (highest on the list)
• Affordability Index: 4.47
• Future growth: $168M I-75/Fruitville interchange upgrade

This is where you buy if you want strong schools and are betting on long-term value appreciation tied to infrastructure growth.

34221 (Palmetto, Manatee County) — The Emerging Growth Zone

• Median sale price: $375,000
• Median income: $74,314
• Affordability Index: 5.05

New construction dominates here, with major builders like D.R. Horton expanding rapidly. Add Manatee’s assistance programs, and it’s a solid choice for buyers seeking modern homes.

34207 (Bradenton, Manatee County) — The Maximum Affordability Option

• Median sale price: $275,000
• Median income: $49,162
• Highlight: Lowest prices in the region

Homes are older and crime is higher, but for budget-conscious buyers, this ZIP makes entry-level ownership possible.

The Psychology of a Buyer’s Market

The stat — 84 days — is more than math. It reflects shifting psychology:

• Sellers worry about carrying costs.
• Agents suggest price drops sooner.
• Builders sweeten deals with upgrades or mortgage rate buy-downs.

This doesn’t mean buyers should lowball recklessly. But it does mean you can negotiate confidently, knowing the data backs you up.

Pitfalls First-Time Buyers Should Avoid

1. Overextending

How to Get Started

Here’s your roadmap to leverage the 84-day advantage:

1. Take a Homebuyer Education Course

Local option: Step Up Suncoast (HUD-approved).

2. Secure Pre-Approval with a Participating Lender

Begin your homebuying journey with confidence by getting pre-approved through Liberty Savings Bank, the local lending partner committed to Sarasota, Manatee, and the entire Gulf Coast community.

3. Work with an Experienced Agent

Find one who knows the nuances of Sarasota vs. Manatee assistance programs.

4. Track Listings by Days on Market

Use Realtor.com or Zillow filters to find homes at 60+ days — these are prime negotiation targets.

In Sarasota, homes are sitting on the market for 84 days. That’s not just a stat — it’s a signal. The tide has shifted. Buyers finally have leverage.

For first-time buyers, this means lower prices, seller concessions, and the breathing room to make smart decisions. By combining local assistance programs, negotiating strategically, and focusing on ZIP codes with the best long-term value, you can turn this moment into your chance at homeownership.

Don’t let the 84-day window pass you by. With preparation and the right guidance, 2025 could be the year you find — and afford — your first home on Florida’s Suncoast.