Medicare Open Enrollment: How to Spot and Stop Scams Before They Hit

Each fall, as the leaves change and the air turns crisp, millions of Americans aged 65 and older prepare to review their Medicare coverage during the Open Enrollment Period, which runs from October 15 to December 7. 

Related Page: PROTECTING YOURSELF FROM COMMON SCAMS IN 2025

It's a time to assess health needs, compare plans, and make informed decisions about healthcare for the coming year. However, this period also marks a peak season for fraudsters who exploit the complexity and urgency of Medicare decisions to deceive beneficiaries.

According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), scammers often pose as Medicare representatives, using tactics like spoofed caller IDs and high-pressure sales pitches to steal personal information. These fraudulent activities not only jeopardize personal finances but also undermine the trust in a system designed to provide security and care.

In this blog post, we'll delve into the most prevalent Medicare Open Enrollment scams, provide actionable steps to protect yourself, and offer resources to report and recover from potential fraud.

Understanding the Common Medicare Scams

1. Impersonation Calls and Spoofing

Scammers often impersonate Medicare representatives, using caller ID spoofing to make their calls appear legitimate. They may claim that your Medicare card is expiring or that you need to update your information to continue receiving benefits. These calls are designed to extract personal details such as your Medicare number, Social Security number, or banking information.

Protective Measures:

• Medicare will never call you unsolicited to ask for personal information.
• If you receive such a call, hang up immediately.
• Contact Medicare directly at 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) to verify any claims.
  
  

2. Phishing Emails and Text Messages

Fraudulent emails or text messages that appear to be from Medicare may contain links directing you to fake websites designed to steal your login credentials or install malware on your device. These messages often create a sense of urgency, warning of account suspensions or offering limited-time benefits.

Protective Measures:

• Do not click on links or download attachments from unsolicited messages.
• Verify the sender's email address or phone number.
• Access your Medicare account by typing "medicare.gov" directly into your browser, rather than clicking on links.
  
  

3. Fake Medicare Plans and Enrollment Offers

Scammers may offer fake Medicare Advantage or Part D prescription drug plans, promising additional benefits or lower costs. They might request payment upfront or ask for personal information to "secure" your enrollment.

Protective Measures:

• Medicare does not endorse specific plans.
• Compare plans using the official Medicare Plan Finder at medicare.gov/plan-compare.
• Consult with your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) for unbiased assistance.
  
  

4. Unsolicited Home Visits or Calls

Some scammers may visit your home or call, claiming to be from Medicare or a Medicare plan, and offer to help you enroll or review your coverage. They might ask for your Medicare number or other personal information.

Protective Measures:

• Medicare representatives do not make unsolicited home visits.
• Do not provide personal information to anyone who contacts you unexpectedly.
• If you feel uncomfortable or pressured, end the interaction and report it.
  
  
  

Steps to Protect Yourself

Guard Your Personal Information

Treat your Medicare number like a credit card number. Only share it with trusted healthcare providers or when you're certain of the legitimacy of the request.

Be Cautious of Unsolicited Communications

Be skeptical of unsolicited calls, emails, or messages, especially those that:

• Ask for personal information.
• Create a sense of urgency.
• Offer "free" gifts or services in exchange for information.
  
  

Verify Before Taking Action

If you're unsure about a communication:

• Hang up and call Medicare directly at 1-800-MEDICARE.
• Use official websites and phone numbers.
• Consult with trusted family members or friends.
  
  

Monitor Your Medicare Statements

Regularly review your Medicare Summary Notices (MSNs) or Explanation of Benefits (EOBs) for any unauthorized services or charges. Report any discrepancies promptly.

Reporting and Recovering from Medicare Scams

If you believe you've been targeted or fallen victim to a Medicare scam:

1. Contact Medicare: Call 1-800-MEDICARE to report the incident and seek guidance.
   
   
2. File a Complaint: Report the scam to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.
   
   
3. Alert Your Bank: If financial information was compromised, notify your bank to monitor and protect your accounts.
   
   
4. Seek Support: Reach out to your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) for assistance in navigating the situation.

Additional Resources

• Medicare.gov: Official site for plan comparisons and enrollment.
• FTC Consumer Alerts: Latest information on scams and fraud prevention.
• Senior Medicare Patrol (SMP): Local programs offering one-on-one assistance and education.
  
  

While the Medicare Open Enrollment Period is an opportunity to ensure your healthcare coverage meets your needs, it's also a time when scammers are most active. By staying informed, being vigilant, and utilizing trusted resources, you can protect yourself from fraud and make confident decisions about your healthcare.

Remember, your health and personal information are invaluable. Don't let fraudsters compromise them. Stay proactive, stay informed, and stay safe.